Years in the past, my iPhone 7 fell off my nightstand, bounced off a plastic field and landed face down on the hardwood ground.

I picked it up, hoping for one of the best, however the display was shattered. Due to an unlucky mixture of physics and karma, the toughest affect was to the underside, the one a part of the system not protected by its


AAPL -0.31%

-branded leather-based case. (The newest Apple instances, for iPhone 12, fully cowl all 4 sides. Finally.)

Apple’s normal guarantee didn’t cowl the harm, regardless that the telephone was simply months-old, as a result of the drop was an accident. The invoice for the display alternative? $140.

Yep, that repair-hit stung. But do I remorse passing up AppleCare+, which might have lowered my out-of-pocket price? Nope.

One cracked display was sufficient of a lesson. Since that fateful incident in 2016, I’ve but to soak up one other telephone for restore. And I’m not alone: A 2016


VZ 0.33%

survey of over 1,000 U.S. adults discovered 49% of respondents had by no means damaged or misplaced their telephone, and 28% had executed so as soon as.

If you, like me, are the sort of one who’s usually cautious along with your telephone and cowl it with a case, then phone-protection plans akin to AppleCare+ ($149 for 2 years) and Samsung Care+ ($216 for 2 years) don’t make sense.

“These are low-probability events by definition. That’s why money is being made by Apple and others,” stated Howard Kunreuther, co-director of the Wharton Risk Management and Decision Processes Center on the University of Pennsylvania. “People focus on the consequences, and they don’t think about the probability.”

Chief among the many issues, says Prof. Kunreuther, is that telephone retailers know the probability of telephone harm—at the least primarily based on the telephones they soak up for restore—however they don’t publish that information. We customers are left to calculate the danger ourselves. And we’re unhealthy at it.

When I went to search for analysis on the subject, a lot of the so-called research had been printed by the businesses intent on promoting protection. They typically had deceptive stats or obtrusive omissions.

If you bought a brand new telephone over the vacations and are contemplating activating a protection plan, I can see the way it seems to make sense. The guarantee included with buy solely covers manufacturing defects, not accidents. And the value of repairs has gone up: A cracked iPhone 6 display in 2015 price $109 to repair—at this time, the equal display swap on an iPhone 12 prices $279, and $199 on a Samsung Galaxy S21. Other iPhone fixes—damaged digicam, malfunctioning mic—can price as much as $449.

Apple quietly expanded protection within the fall, making the AppleCare+ program seem like extra of a deal. Customers now can declare two situations of harm every year, as a substitute of two claims each two years. The Theft and Loss plan (an extra $70 on prime of fundamental AppleCare+) now expenses a $149 deductible for stolen or misplaced telephones, down from $269.

Years in the past, my iPhone 7 fell off my nightstand, bounced off a plastic field and landed face down on the hardwood ground.

Apple expanded protection within the AppleCare+ program this fall; the iPhone 12 launch in Sydney in November.


Brendon Thorne/Bloomberg News

When you take a look at particular person numbers, it could possibly look like shopping for protection saves you cash. Only $29 for an iPhone or Galaxy display restore! But don’t neglect to think about that premium.

There are a whole lot of numbers to consider, so let’s take a look at a few price situations. First, right here’s what could be of gravest concern for somebody who simply purchased a high-end iPhone:

Broken iPhone 12 Screen

• $279 – If you don’t have protection and break your iPhone display.

• $178 – If you prepay for 2 years of AppleCare+ and break your display.

• $149 – If you purchased the plan and don’t break your display.

• $0 – If you don’t have a plan and don’t break your display.

Maybe you aren’t liable to breakage however frightened a couple of stolen or misplaced telephone. Here’s how that shakes out with



Lost Samsung Galaxy S21 Phone

• $799 – If you don’t have protection and lose your new Galaxy.

• $541 – If you pay for 2 years of Samsung Care+ and lose your telephone.

• $312 – If you pay for 2 years of Samsung Care+ and don’t lose the telephone.

• $0 – If you don’t have protection and don’t lose your telephone.

The most essential consideration is chance. Are you prepared to wager Apple that you’ll positively break your display? Or wager Samsung that your telephone will certainly be misplaced? Sure, somebody studying this would possibly skip the protection plan and remorse it later, however statistically that particular person is within the minority.

Also, your chance of harm goes manner down in case you slap on a high-quality case made with a non-slick materials and raised edges that can shield the show. You might even add a PopSocket or ring for an much more safe grip.

Plus, smartphone shows are getting extra sturdy. Apple says the newest iPhone 12 gadgets have a show with 4 instances the drop safety. Meanwhile, Samsung claims the S21’s Gorilla Glass Victus is the hardest glass on a Samsung smartphone.

Years in the past, my iPhone 7 fell off my nightstand, bounced off a plastic field and landed face down on the hardwood ground.

Samsung claims the Galaxy S21’s glass is the hardest of any of its smartphones; the Galaxy S21 Ultra 5G smartphone.


SeongJoon Cho/Bloomberg News

You might not even want to think about the coverage-plan wager. Some bank cards supply telephone safety as a profit. Chase Freedom Flex, for instance, contains theft or harm insurance coverage for telephones, so long as you pay your month-to-month cellphone invoice along with your Chase card. The deductible is $50 and you can also make two claims a 12 months.

Many householders and renters insurance coverage insurance policies don’t cowl unintentional harm, however they do embrace theft out of the house beneath private property protection. This covers smartphones, though deductibles are sometimes excessive. My coverage’s deductible is $1,000—nicely above the price of an iPhone 12. But if somebody stole a backpack that included your telephone, laptop computer and different valuables, you’d be coated. Hippo, a homeowners-insurance startup, and Toggle, the renters-insurance arm of Farmers, lets clients choose their deductible when selecting a coverage, as little as $500 on Hippo and $100 on Toggle.

When You Should Buy a Plan

The economics could be totally different in case you can’t afford to attend for repairs—Apple and Samsung supply alternative telephones as quickly as the following day, and some insurance policy by way of mobile carriers can ship even the identical day.

Otherwise, these prolonged protection choices are greatest for big-time klutzes. If you break a telephone at the least every year, then positive, enroll. The query is, which plan? You should buy prolonged protection out of your telephone’s producer, your cell service, or a 3rd occasion.

Most require you to enroll inside a sure interval after buy, 60 days for AppleCare+ and one 12 months for Samsung Care+. Samsung’s theft and loss protection is out there solely on the time of buy.


Do you get warranties on your tech purchases? Why or why not? Join the dialog beneath.

Some corporations, akin to Progressive and SquareTrade, will let you register your telephone, used or new, at any time with a purchase order receipt. And no, in case you break your telephone, then join the plan, your pre-existing crack isn’t coated. (That’s insurance coverage fraud.)

Progressive has a comparatively reasonably priced deductible for theft and loss: $75, with two-year premiums ranging between $169 and $175, relying in your telephone. But there’s a caveat: Its protection doesn’t kick in till 30 days after you enroll.

SquareTrade has a versatile $9 month-to-month price, with a flat $149 deductible for all harm claims, however no protection for theft or loss. This may very well be an excellent non permanent possibility for, say, vacationers.

Cell carriers are inclined to cost probably the most.


telephone insurance coverage is $15 a month, greater than any of the ten plans I in contrast. It does, nevertheless, supply spectacular perks, together with same-day system alternative or restore, as much as three claims a 12 months, $29 display restore, theft-and-loss protection and limitless house in AT&T’s Photo Storage app. Even in case you by no means use these different perks, at the least you’ll be able to really make use of that picture storage.

No matter what you resolve, my major recommendation is that this: Get a case to guard your funding and, even when your telephone is marketed as “water resistant,” preserve it away from saltwater.

(Dow Jones & Co., writer of The Wall Street Journal, has a business settlement to produce information by way of Apple providers.)

Write to Nicole Nguyen at [email protected]

Copyright ©2020 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 87990cbe856818d5eddac44c7b1cdeb8